Skip to main content

TRADITION IN EVERY SLICE

Est 1962

Order Online Now

Menu Favorites

Try one of our most popular items and see why we’re known as one of the best spots in town for pizza, wings, subs, and more.

OUR STORY

We are proud to be family owned and operated for 3 generations and over 60 years in business.

Sammy Musolino was the originator of the “1/2 Tray” of pizza, a tradition that has become a staple in our community and a go-to choice for family dinners, parties, and gatherings throughout Niagara Falls.

From our signature pizzas to hearty pasta dishes and classic wings, everything we serve is made with the same care that’s kept customers coming back decade after decade.

A neighborhood favorite for generations.

IN-HOUSE FULL BAR

Craft cocktails, beer, and wine available to enjoy with your meal.

CARRY-OUT & DELIVERY

Order online and enjoy our food at home with fast pickup or delivery.

LARGE BANQUET ROOM

Perfect for parties, celebrations, and private events of all sizes.

From Our Kitchen to Your Table

Ordering your favorites from Sammy’s Pizzeria is fast, easy, and convenient.

ORDER ONLINE
Everyday Specials

Everyday Specials

ORDER NOW
Wings & Appetizers

Wings & Appetizers

ORDER NOW
Specialty Pizzas

Specialty Pizzas

ORDER NOW
Strombolis & Calzones

Strombolis & Calzones

ORDER NOW
Pasta

Pasta

ORDER NOW
Subs & Sandwiches

Subs & Sandwiches

ORDER NOW

Why Locals Choose Sammy’s Pizzeria

You can find pure American vibes here. Our waitress Crystal was extremely friendly and helpful. We had an amazing dining experience at Sammy's
Shin O on Google
Had a wonderful experience after visiting Niagara Falls. Food was almost as amazing as my server Crystal who was so kind and attentive. Also the endearing small town American vibes made it a wonderful escape from the tourist traps at Niagara Falls.
Haley Whelan on Google
We had a great time at Sammy's! Excellent pizza and friendly staff. Family owned & operated! Highly recommend if you find yourself in Niagara Falls!
K Bennett on Google

FAQs

Sammy's Pizza has been proudly serving Niagara Falls since 1962 and has remained family-owned and operated for three generations. We're known for our original recipes, fresh ingredients, and being the home of the famous Half Tray Pizza, a local favorite created by our founder, Sammy Musolino.

Our Half Tray Pizza is a Niagara Falls tradition featuring 15 square-cut slices of our signature tray-style pizza. It's perfect for families, parties, game nights, and anyone looking to enjoy one of Western New York's most iconic pizza styles.

Yes! You can conveniently order online for pickup or delivery directly through our website. Ordering direct gives you the fastest and easiest way to enjoy your favorite Sammy's Pizza menu items.

Absolutely. We offer local delivery throughout Niagara Falls and nearby neighborhoods, making it easy to enjoy fresh pizza, wings, pasta, subs, and more from the comfort of your home.

We offer something for every pizza lover, including: New York Style Pizza Niagara Falls Style Tray Pizza Detroit Style Pizza Chicago Deep Dish Pizza Stuffed Crust Pizza Gluten-Free Pizza Specialty Pizzas with dozens of unique topping combinations.

Customer favorites include: Half Tray Pizza Old Fashioned Pizza Buffalo Chicken Pizza 716 Pizza Wings Beef on Weck Strombolis Calzones Pasta Dinners Steak & Cheese Subs

Yes. We offer gluten-free pizza crust along with a gluten-free pizza bowl, giving guests more options without sacrificing flavor.

Yes. Sammy's Pizza is a favorite for family dinners, office lunches, birthday parties, and special events. We offer tray pizzas, wing combinations, and large portions perfect for feeding groups.

Yes. Sammy's Pizza has proudly remained family owned and operated for over 60 years and is now run by the third generation of the Musolino family.

Yes. Guests are welcome to enjoy a relaxed dine-in experience complete with our full bar, friendly service, and comfortable dining room.

Yes. Sammy's Pizza features a spacious banquet room that's ideal for birthday parties, graduation celebrations, business meetings, sports banquets, and family gatherings.

Sammy's Pizza is conveniently located at 1400 Hyde Park Blvd, Niagara Falls, NY, proudly serving guests throughout Niagara Falls, LaSalle, Niagara University, Hyde Park, Little Italy, North End LaSalle, Downtown Niagara Falls, East Side, Cayuga Island, Love Canal, Colonial Village, Lewiston, Wheatfield, Sanborn, and Grand Island.

VISIT US

Sign up for deals and promotions
We have sent you a password reset email.
Click the button in the email to reset your password.
Terms & Privacy