Order online
A full tray of Sammy's pepperoni pizza, cut into squares on the kitchen counter

Niagara Falls, N.Y. · Est. 1962

Tradition in every slice

Gather for a meal, settle in for a drink, or take your favorites to go.

Order onlineSee the menu
  • HoursMon – Tue 11:15 AM – 12:30 AMWed 11:30 AM – 12:30 AMThu 11:15 AM – 12:30 AMFri – Sat 11:15 AM – 1:30 AMSun 11:15 AM – 12:30 AM
  • Find us1400 Hyde Park Blvd, Niagara Falls
  • Call(716) 297-8442

Menu favorites

What Niagara Falls orders

Three of the most popular things in the kitchen. Start here if it's your first time, or go straight to the full menu.

See the full menu

Everyday specials

Pie & wings, every day

A pizza and a basket of Buffalo wings, priced together. Pick your tray, pick your count, pick your sauce.

  1. Medium Pie (1 Item) + 10 Wings$24.95
  2. Medium Pie (1 Item) + 20 Wings$36.95
  3. 1/2 Tray (1 Item) + 10 Wings$25.95
  4. 1/2 Tray (1 Item) + 20 Wings$38.95
  5. Party Tray (1 Item) + 30 Wings$64.95
  6. Party Tray (1 Item) + 50 Wings$74.95
  7. Personal Pie (1 Item) + 5 Wings$10.25
  8. Personal Deep Dish (One Item) + 5 Wings$14.95
  9. Personal Specialty Pizza + 5 Wings$14.95

Specials are available for pickup, delivery and dine-in. Delivery is a flat $4 fee up to 5 miles, with our own drivers. Combos and prices come straight from our menu.

Order a special
Sammy's exterior building with large mural

Our story

Family owned for three generations

We are proud to be family owned and operated for 3 generations and over 60 years in business.

Sammy Musolino was the originator of the “1/2 Tray” of pizza, a tradition that has become a staple in our community and a go-to choice for family dinners, parties, and gatherings throughout Niagara Falls.

From our signature pizzas to hearty pasta dishes and classic wings, everything we serve is made with the same care that’s kept customers coming back decade after decade.

Great Pizza. Good Company.

Two rooms, one kitchen

Dine in, carry out, or book the room

  • full bar stocked with bottles

    In-house full bar

    Craft cocktails, beer and wine with your meal, and the game on at the bar.

    Hours & location
  • A Sammy's pizza box with pizza in it

    Carry-out & delivery

    Order online and enjoy Sammy's at home: fast pickup, or local delivery around Niagara Falls.

    Order online
  • Interior of Sammy's with tables, a fireplace, and neon Sammy's sign

    Large banquet room

    Birthdays, graduations, business meetings, sports banquets: private events of every size.

    Plan an event

From our kitchen to your table

Order your favorites online

Fast, easy and convenient. Pick a category to start an order for pickup or delivery.

We use our own driversFlat $4 delivery fee up to 5 miles

Order online

Why locals choose Sammy's

Kind words from the dining room

Straight from Google: regulars, first-timers, and folks who crossed the border for the wings.

  1. Excellent Pizza, and EXCELLENT Buffalo Wings. The service was also incredible. Everyone was kind and helpful. It was as always a wonderfully pleasant experience. Can't recommend the wings enough.

  2. Great wings and pizza! We have been coming to Sammy's for over 10 years now. Service had been very poor in the past, however our last visit on March 21st, 2026 surprised us with how well the service was. I've also noticed some minor renovations have been made, such as repainting the walls.

  3. Went to Sammy's for a pregame meal on our way over to Sabres game based on a recommendation. We live in nearby Niagara, ON and are always looking to try different pizza & wing spots in NY. Sammy's lived up to the amazing reputation & recommendation. The pizza is top tier, the pepperoni are nice large cup n char style, and heavy distribution. The cheese is what we go across the border for, it just hits different in the states, and the sauce, crust & cook wrapped it all together perfectly. The wings were classic Buffalo wings, amazing flavour, some of the best I've ever had. Sammy's is going to be one of my top spots on any trip over the river and I can't recommend it enough! The pub vibes are classic Americana, nothing fancy but just what we were after (we sat in the pub, although they do have a nice size dining room as well!). Karen gave us great service! They've been doing it for 63years so you know they're doing something right! Do not miss this legendary spot.

Good to know

Questions we get a lot

The short answers. The long ones are in the dining room.

See all questions

What makes Sammy's different from other pizzerias in Niagara Falls?
Sammy's has been family owned and operated since 1962, three generations of the Musolino family. The recipes are the originals, the dough is made in our kitchen every day, and the Half Tray that founder Sammy Musolino created is still the pizza the neighborhood orders for family dinners, parties and game nights.
What is the Half Tray pizza?
Fifteen square-cut slices of our tray-style pizza, a Niagara Falls tradition. It feeds a family, a table of friends or a living room on game night, and it's a Western New York classic. A Full Tray is thirty slices.
Do you offer online ordering?
Yes. Order pizza, wings, subs and the rest of the menu online for pickup or delivery. It's the fastest and easiest way to get Sammy's to your table.
Do you deliver in Niagara Falls?
Yes. We deliver locally throughout Niagara Falls and the nearby neighborhoods, including LaSalle, Hyde Park, Niagara University, Lewiston, Wheatfield, Sanborn and Grand Island. Pizza, wings, pasta, subs and more.
What kinds of pizza do you make?
New York style pies, Niagara Falls style trays, Detroit style, Chicago deep dish, stuffed crust, gluten-free crusts, and more than twenty specialty pizzas, from the Old Fashioned to the 7-1-6.
What are the most popular items?
The Half Tray, the Old Fashioned pizza, Sammy's Original Buffalo Chicken Wing pizza, the 7-1-6 pizza, Buffalo wings, Beef on Weck, strombolis and calzones, pasta dinners, and the Steak & Cheese Sub.

Hours & location

Come find us on Hyde Park Boulevard

A family dining room, a bar with the game on, and a kitchen that stays open late every night of the week.

Address

1400 Hyde Park BlvdNiagara Falls, NY 14305
Get directions

Phone

(716) 297-8442

Hours

Monday
11:15 AM – 12:30 AM
Tuesday
11:15 AM – 12:30 AM
Wednesday
11:30 AM – 12:30 AM
Thursday
11:15 AM – 12:30 AM
Friday
11:15 AM – 1:30 AM
Saturday
11:15 AM – 1:30 AM
Sunday
11:15 AM – 12:30 AM
The Sammy's Pizzeria storefront on Hyde Park Boulevard